Direct answer: Yes. California's voluntary disclosure cuts the look-back from eight years to three with penalty relief available; New Jersey typically looks at four years and waives penalties. You must apply before the state contacts you, interest is not waived, and tax collected but not remitted gets no relief.

A typical call: a Shopify store placed inventory in third-party warehouses in California and New Jersey more than two years ago for delivery speed, never registered for sales tax, and has just received a "business activities questionnaire" forwarded by the warehouse. The owner's first question is always "how many years and how much penalty"; the second is "can we fix this without waking up the state." Both point to the same tool: the state voluntary disclosure agreement (VDA). This article lays out the terms, entry points, sequencing and traps of the California and New Jersey programs, and compares them with simply registering and filing the back returns.

1. First confirm that you actually have an obligation in each state

Voluntary disclosure is for people who had an obligation and did not meet it, so step one is to pin the obligation down. Inventory stored in a warehouse inside the state creates physical presence regardless of who owns the facility or who signed the contract; registration, collection and filing are required from the receiving date. California and New Jersey agree on this. Without a warehouse, the economic nexus thresholds apply: California requires registration when sales of tangible personal property delivered into the state exceed $500,000 in the preceding or current calendar year (AB 147, effective April 1, 2019); New Jersey when gross revenue delivered into the state exceeds $100,000 or there are 200 or more separate transactions in the current or prior calendar year (P.L. 2018, c. 132, effective November 1, 2018), counting marketplace and direct sales together.

TestCalifornia (CDTFA)New Jersey (Division of Taxation)
Inventory in an in-state 3PLPhysical presence from the receiving datePhysical presence "regardless of ownership of the facility"
Economic nexus thresholdMore than $500,000 of tangible goods delivered into California in the preceding or current yearMore than $100,000 gross revenue, or 200 or more transactions, in the current or prior year
EffectiveApril 1, 2019 (AB 147)November 1, 2018 (P.L. 2018, c. 132)
Marketplace salesFacilitator collects, but marketplace sales still count toward your thresholdFacilitator collects; a marketplace-only seller above the threshold must still register and may request non-reporting status (Form C-6205-ST)
After crossing the thresholdRegister and begin collectingRegister and begin collecting within 30 days
  • A 3PL equals physical presence, whatever the dollar amount
  • Economic thresholds: California $500,000; New Jersey $100,000 or 200 transactions
  • You collect on direct-store orders; the marketplace collects on its orders; both count toward the threshold
  • Fix the date the obligation began, or the look-back has no starting point

2. The core terms of both programs, side by side

California's program is in Revenue and Taxation Code §6487.05, the Out-of-State Voluntary Disclosure Program, aimed at retailers located outside California that have never registered with CDTFA, are engaged in business in the state and failed to collect use tax. The central benefit is a look-back limited to three years instead of the statutory eight; late-filing and late-payment penalties may be relieved on a statement, signed under penalty of perjury, attached to Form CDTFA-38. New Jersey has no separate statute; the Division runs the program administratively. A business submits a VDA Fact Pattern Form and a written proposal, the Division issues an agreement, all penalties for the covered periods are waived, and the look-back in practice is typically the current year plus three prior years. The Division's own page warns that a business found through a nexus investigation instead "could face unlimited look-back years."

TermCalifornia Out-of-State VDPNew Jersey VDP (business)
AuthorityR&TC §6487.05Division administrative program (Voluntary Disclosure Program page)
EligibilityLocated outside California; never registered; voluntary; no prior contact by CDTFA; failure due to reasonable cause, not intentNot registered but willing to register; no prior contact; not under criminal investigation; willing to file, pay and stay compliant
Look-back3 years (statutory 8)Typically 4 years (current + 3 prior), per the agreement; unlimited if discovered by audit
PenaltiesLate-filing and late-payment penalties may be relieved on a reasonable-cause statementAll penalties for covered periods waived
Not relievedInterest; the program does not apply to sales tax or to anyone who holds or held a seller's permitInterest; a non-abatable 5% penalty on trust-fund tax collected but not remitted; a separate 5% for old periods covered by the amnesty that closed in January 2019
AnonymityAnonymous written opinion available from the Voluntary Disclosure Specialist; the formal application is in your nameA representative may submit the fact pattern first; the Division assigns an ID, then you identify yourself
Entry pointRegister through CDTFA Online Services, then mail CDTFA-38 to the Out-of-State Office in Sacramento within 30 daysSubmit the VDA Fact Pattern Form and written proposal to the Office Audit Branch
OutcomeAcceptance or denial letter; file and pay online once acceptedExecuted agreement stating taxes, start date and return due dates; complete NJ-REG registration and the Nexus Questionnaire
  • California: three years versus eight; the difference is five years of tax plus interest
  • New Jersey: four years versus unlimited, and penalties are waived in full
  • Interest is never waived in either state; it is the unavoidable part of the cost
  • "No prior contact" is a hard condition; applying after a questionnaire arrives usually fails it

3. Two sequencing traps in California

The first trap is in the statute itself. §6487.05 speaks of use tax, the tax a retailer collects when goods ship from outside the state to a California consumer. Once goods sit in a California warehouse and ship from there to California buyers, those transactions are sales tax under California law, and CDTFA's program page states plainly that the program does not apply to sales subject to California sales tax or to anyone who holds or has held a seller's permit. For a seller with a California 3PL, the largest slice of its sales is exactly the slice whose eligibility for the three-year limit cannot be assumed. The right move is to describe the flow of goods (order, warehouse, shipment, delivery address) in an anonymous request, obtain CDTFA's written opinion, and only then file the formal application.

The second trap is order of operations. CDTFA's page cautions that entering a Secretary of State (SOS) number on the CDTFA online registration, or establishing an SOS registration first, disqualifies you from the Franchise Tax Board's voluntary disclosure program. A company with a California warehouse has usually also triggered California income tax and minimum franchise tax filing obligations. If both are unfiled, apply to the FTB program first and do the CDTFA registration and VDA second; reversing the order trades away one of the two sets of relief.

  • California warehouse to California buyer equals sales tax; the statute says use tax, so ask anonymously first
  • Tax collected from customers and not remitted gets no relief in either state
  • Income tax unfiled too: FTB first, CDTFA second
  • New Jersey's proposal must also state whether any collected tax went unremitted

4. Four data sets to assemble before you apply

Both states' forms require you to state when business activity began and roughly how much is owed. If you cannot, the state will estimate on its own terms and the start of the look-back is no longer yours to set. Prepare four data sets before applying: sales and order counts by state, by channel (direct store versus marketplace) and by month, for thresholds and tax computation; the first receiving date at each 3PL and inventory records, to fix the start of physical presence; whether checkout ever charged customers "tax" or a tax-labelled fee, which decides whether trust-fund tax is involved; and, for California, delivery addresses broken down by district, because local add-on rates differ by city and county.

DataUsed forSource
Sales and order counts by state × channel × monthThresholds, tax computation, estimated liability on the applicationShopify / marketplace exports, summarized by ship-to state
First receiving date and inventory detail at each 3PLStart of physical presence, i.e. start of the look-backReceiving documents, WMS reports
Whether checkout charged customers taxDistinguishes tax you absorb from trust-fund taxCheckout settings history, order tax fields
Delivery district of California ordersState rate plus district add-onsOrder addresses → CDTFA rate lookup

A sanitized example: a Chinese-owned company selling home goods through its own store placed inventory in California and New Jersey 3PLs in early 2024, never registered for sales tax, and never charged customers tax at checkout. After a self-review in autumn 2026, the New Jersey side went in through a representative with a fact pattern first; the agreement ran from the 2024 receiving date with penalties waived and tax plus interest paid by the company. The California side obtained an anonymous opinion on the flow of goods before filing CDTFA-38, with the look-back held to three years. Because customers were never charged tax, neither state's trust-fund penalty or exclusion applied. The total was not small, but it was far less than an eight-year or unlimited look-back plus penalties after a questionnaire.

  • Data before application: you write the start date and the estimate
  • State × channel × month is the minimum granularity
  • Never having charged customers tax is the key fact for the best terms
  • California orders must be split by district; local add-ons cannot be skipped

5. Voluntary disclosure or simply register and file?

Not every case justifies a VDA. If only a year or two is open, the amount is modest and there has been no contact, registering and filing the prior returns directly is faster; California's late-filing and late-payment penalties can be requested for relief on the same reasonable-cause basis, without waiting for an agreement. Many years, large amounts or several states are where a VDA earns its keep: it fixes the look-back and removes penalties, which a direct back-filing cannot. If any contact has already arrived (a questionnaire, a notice, an inquiry forwarded by the warehouse), a VDA is usually no longer available and the focus shifts to reasonable-cause relief and a payment plan.

FactorVoluntary disclosure (VDA)Register and back-file directly
Look-backCalifornia limited to 3 years; New Jersey typically 4Statutory period (California can reach 8 years for the unregistered)
PenaltiesCalifornia relief on request; New Jersey waivedRelief only by individual reasonable-cause requests
InterestNot waivedNot waived
IdentityTerms can be explored anonymously firstNamed from the moment of registration
TimeWait for the department's reply and agreementFile as soon as registered
FitsMany years, large amounts, several statesOne or two years, small amounts, one state
PreconditionNo prior contactNone
  • Many years and large amounts: VDA; one or two years and small amounts: back-file
  • Already contacted: move to reasonable-cause relief and installments
  • Both routes start with the state-by-state data
  • The ongoing filings after the catch-up are the real cost; do not fixate on the one-time payment